Keen on Birding

Sam Keen’s lovely book of autobiographical essays on birding was released in September last year. The full title is Sightings: Extraordinary Encounters with Ordinary Birds. Accompanied by delicate watercolor-like illustrations by Mary Woodin, Keen talks of birding as a religious experience. According to him, modern birders, though they do not worship birds, resemble a “neo-pagan cult, practitioners of a theology of nature.” He begins by writing about his childhood experiences when, dissatisfied and puzzled by the church that he attended as a child, he began to look to birding as his spiritual refuge.

Keen’s musings on birding and spirituality are very charming and it is clear that he has visited the matter frequently, having been a professor of philosophy and religion. I think that they will resonate with readers who do not have a scientific background, but to someone with more than a passing interest in biology, they might leave a tiny bit to be desired. I do not mean to say this as a knock on the book, because I thoroughly enjoyed reading it and believe that a writer must not be asked to tailor his output for anyone. I am concerned however, that with all the essays extolling the spiritual relevance of the birding experience, it might seem that this is the definitive purpose, if not the only purpose of birding and that the more technical aspects of ornithology are not sufficiently charming except to the specialist.


That minor quibble apart, the essays and their well-placed illustrations make for quiet, pleasurable reading and are excellent companions over a cup of hot afternoon tea (to those who have the luxury of enjoying a cup of hot afternoon tea away from work. I happen to have devoured it in three readings, mostly in the dead of night. Now, I read some of the essays again at my leisure.). One of my favorite essays is the piece about the northern cardinal. Keen writes about Miss Beach, a young art teacher in his school who accompanied the teenage author on his birding jaunts and shared a beautiful secret relationship with him. He says he was never very good at art, and a misshapen cardinal that he had drawn in her class became a token of their shared love of birdwatching. For many years after the boy left his small town, Miss Beach would write lavishly illustrated letters about her bird sightings, sometimes drawing a cardinal in the place of a return address on the envelope. It is impossible to remain unmoved while reading The Everlasting Cardinal.

Most of the essays concern experiences with fairly common birds of the backyard, the shore and the city such as turkeys, sparrows, thrushes, hawks and Keen revels in the enjoyment and amusement of observing and being observed. He writes that his love affair with birds was ignited by a sighting of the indigo bunting:

The bunting was the first of many slant revelations and incarnate metaphors that spoke to me of the primal sacredness of life. They form the basis of my creed as expressed by D.H. Lawrence: “There is a sixth sense, the natural religious sense, the sense of wonder”.

Many of us have this recollection of the one bird we have seen that first piqued our interest in birding as an activity. I would love to think that my subconscious mind was entranced by the peacocks who roamed the parks where the young parents took a stroll with a two-year-old inside a pram, but this is too good to be true. I remember nothing of the peacocks though I recall the blue-white pram quite vividly. What I do remember is that, as an eleven-year-old member of the school’s World Wide Fund for Nature, I went to a lake out of town. There by the lakeshore, shortly before we camped, we saw a solitary pink flamingo in the failing light.

5 thoughts on “Keen on Birding”

  1. I love cardinals, a bright streak of red flashing by in winter is a beautiful sight. We had a pair nest in a tree in our backyard one summer. Listening to them calling back and forth and to the chicks was such a treat. And I will always get a thrill in spring when I see my first robin and in fall when I hear the first flock of geese honking their way across the sky. Hmmm, I just might have to look this book up!

    Love your bird drawing!

  2. Hello. I’ve been a little bit familiar with Sam Keen and a lot familiar with birding (having birded seriously for over 26 years). The book sounds interesting; thanks for recommending it.

  3. Stefanie: It must have been a treat to be able to watch the cardinals nesting. It is a lot of fun to trace the paths taken by the male and the female as they flit through the hedges, they appear to be following each other. About robins, are they considered harbingers of spring here in the US? There are robins in India but they look very different – much smaller and all black. The ones here are much larger with reddish chest and belly.

    Thanks for the compliment about the drawing. It is a vector drawing of a nuthatch.

    Steve: Welcome, and thanks for visiting. I’ll be curious to know what you think of the book. The goldfinch picture on your blog is awesome, as is the one with the snake’s eye reflecting the church roof.. I think I am going to have a great time checking out your posts.

  4. Yes, robins in the US, the ones with the big red chests, are considered harbingers of spring. They generally show up in Minneapolis about the time most of the snow has melted and the ground is beginning to thaw.

Leave a Reply to Stefanie Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s